Menu to Taste

Café Carmellini

French, Italian · New York · Chef Andrew Carmellini

Ranked No. 39 on North America's 50 Best Restaurants list, Café Carmellini is chef Andrew Carmellini's fine-dining destination in New York. The kitchen marries French and Italian culinary traditions through dishes like crab mille-feuille with Meyer lemon sauce inside a grand space anchored by two sculptural trees.

250 5th Ave, New York, NY 10001, New York

  • NA 50 Best
  • #39 North America's 50 Best 2025

Menu

Dishes

  • Atlantic Halibut (60) — Sauce Cresson
  • Oysters à la Pomme (26)
  • Smoked Egg Salad & Caviar Katsu
  • Avocado & Egg Tartlet
  • Smoked Salmon Benedict
  • Homemade Pastry Assortment (22) — Served with Cultured Butter and Preserves
  • Fresh Seasonal Fruit Plate (20)
  • Sheep’s Milk Yogurt (21) — Mixed Berries, Wildflower Honey, Bee Pollen
  • Coconut Yogurt Parfait (22) — Tropical Fruit, Vegan Yogurt, Granola, Basil Seeds
  • McCann’s Steel-Cut Oatmeal (20) — Stewed Cherries, Puffed Grains, Sicilian Pistachio

Set Menu

  • Two-Course Menu (75) — Served Saturday & Sunday, 11:30am to 2:30pm (per person)
  • Osetra Caviar Service Supplement (190) — Supplement for Osetra Caviar Service

Cocktails

  • Chartreuse Gimlet (25) — Green Chartreuse, Yuzu, Lime Cordial
  • Strawberry Kingston Negroni (25) — Rum, Vermouth, Day Trip Amaro
  • Pineapple-Sweet Pepper Margarita (25) — Tequila, Yellow Bell, Ancho
  • Sugar Baby Punch (25) — Rum, Coconut, Watermelon
  • Brandy Crusta (25) — Cognac, Almond, Grapefruit
  • Limoncello Fizz (25) — Suze, Vanilla, Egg White
  • Fifty-Fifty Martini (25) — Gin, Lillet, Rose Petal Jam
  • Fichi Americano (25) — Vermouth, Campari, Fig Leaf Soda
  • Cavaillon G&T (25) — Gin, Tarragon, Melon

Wines

  • Vajra ‘N.S. Della Neve’ Rosato Extra Brut (27) — Piedmont, Italy
  • Tement Sauvignon Blanc 'Kalk & Kreide' (28) — 2024 - Sudsteirermark, Austria
  • F.X. Pichler Grüner Veltliner Federspiel (31) — ‘Loibner’ 2024 - Wachau, Austria
  • Tiberio Pecorino (25) — 2024 - Abruzzo, Italy
  • Franz Hirtzberger 'Steinerterrasen' Riesling (33) — 2023 - Wachau, Austria
  • Remoissenet Bourgogne Blanc (39) — 2022 - Burgundy, France
  • JL Chave Selections Hermitage Blanche (58) — 2022 - Rhône, France
  • Château Peyrassol 'Les Commandeurs' (25) — 2025 - Côtes de Provence, France
  • Antoine Graillot Côtes-du-Rhône 'Clos Somi' (27) — 2023 - Rhône, France
  • Lionel Faury Saint Joseph ‘Les Ribaudes’ (35) — 2022 - Rhône, France

The Experience

A theatrical and opulent room in a historic setting. A good fit for celebrations and a romantic evening.

Phone: +12122319200

Related restaurants